I know a lot of you were asking me to write about my experiences in the US, I refrained from it for a lot of reasons. Today’s experience, however, was just screaming out to be written about and shared.
For our class assignment at the J-school, Columbia University, we were to choose a place and profile it. In my zealous addiction to History and a mad drive to do something different, I decided to profile Stonewall Inn.
Stonewall Inn is a bar whose history with gay rights dates back to 1967. It is the site of Stonewall Riots, which many believe was the visible start of the gay rights movement in the US. So, my project was looking at how things have changed in these 40-odd years, if at all.
With a lot of vigour and enthusiasm about the new assignment, I stepped into Stonewall. While I was mentally prepared to see some rather explicit ‘performances’, my mind was still not communicating with my senses. I must have given a slight squeak, and my eyes must have popped open when I walked in. Being the professional that I am, I quickly regained my composure and strode in.
Once inside, I actually marvelled at the various couples sitting there - an African American man with a man from the Far East, two White women and an Asian man with two White men. And within minutes, I was feeling comfortable sitting in my cosy corner.
I began speaking to the bar tender who was a very pleasant lesbian woman. She tried her very best to find people who I could interview. But with little avail. So, I hung around hoping someone might want to face the mike. I felt it impolite to not order for a drink, so, I asked her to fetch me a beer. For the record, I hate beers! I looked at it as a professional hazard. Well, my profession seems to be quite hazardous, as I later found out! The beer cost me $6 and as tips are a must in the US, with the heaviest heart, I slipped in two one dollar bills. That is how much I would spend on one lavish meal! And remember, I still had no story. No one was willing to be interviewed yet!
In the meanwhile, a girl who was darting her eyes over me now and then, walked over to me. It got me slightly worried. I was not sure what to say, how to react. She wanted to know more about my T-shirt. I relaxed. But suddenly, she said, ‘I like the way you hold your beer’. Oh! This is what I dreaded! By the time one reaches my age, one gets used to boys hitting on you almost every day. You know how to politely reject their advances, or just tell them to back-off at times. But I had never been hit on by a woman before. I tried doing what I would do if a boy had used that rather horrible pick up line. I asked her if she would like to be interviewed. It worked! She rejected the offer and said ‘yeah, you look the kinds men would like. I am sure a lot of men fall for you’. Smiled, and left.
I was left introspecting, ashamed at my awkward behaviour.
But, as my interviewee later said, the gay and lesbian community probably need their own islands of seclusion, where they can be themselves, unhindered. I finally interviewed a man who insisted on putting his sexuality as his primary identity, over nationality. He has been visiting the Stonewall Inn for the past 23 years.
The experience that evening was a unique and a very educating one. And, I managed to get a good story! It was a true journalism experience.
Raksha Kumar
9 comments:
first, why would you be scared if a woman hits on you? She is not coming to kill you? She is just expressing her likeness/attraction for you!
Plus,Why would 'performances' shock you? when they are not performances?
Why would the girl say homos need secluded spaces sometimes? Because they can have sex in public in a place that is more seemingly private than other places?
Who has the responsiblity of shattering existing ideas about homesexuals having sex in public?
If gay men and women need to continue to return to their secluded space to be able to do what they want to do...well then 'straight' - hate this word - people would feel the same way? They need to have sex in their pirvate space. No? so this differentiation is misplaced.
Plus... take gay men women at face value!
forgive my outburts,
on a more level-headed note, it is an honest account
I do not blame you for what you felt and for what she felt. Guess she too sensed what u felt and probably thats why she shot off the sarcastic lines!
Hey Raksha!!
Really like the way you have written. I do not know much about the technicalities or the prejudices and how they should be written about. But I really liked reading what you have written and it kept me hooked right till the end. Great! :)
@ Suketu, let me answer your questions one by one. And, no, your oubursts did not offend me even the slightest. So, there is not need to apologise at all.
Why would I be scared? I never was. I never said I was. I was uncomfortable. Let us understand that each has a personal space. Just as gays and lesbians feel comfortable if members of their own sex intruded it, hetrosexuals (even I hate the word 'straight' to refer to hetrosexuals) feel comfortable only if members of the opposite sex intrude that space.
Now, the girl was clearly seeking something from me that I couldn't give. Turning down any inuendo is slightly tricky. Here it is even more tricky as it has never happened before. I could not have offended her or made her feel ashamed for what she did. So, I was just tense about what to say. It is like when you are 13 and someone makes a pass at you for the first time in your life. How would you react? It is not flattering at the first go. It is plain uncomfortable.
Suketu, you need to diffentiate between 'discomfort' and 'fear'. I was hesitant. Nothing else.
Two, why would 'performances' shock me? Okay, I feel there are two things here: the western society in general is very 'open'. So, they are a lot more explicit in public spaces than we can ever be in the near future. So, while you have hetrosexual couples making out in public (literally in the subway, road, retaurant etc) homosexuals couples do not. Because they'd be frowned upon. So, my second reading of the situation is that they get even more explicit in an environment like a gay bar. To be extremely honest with you, I had never seen men touching each others most private parts in public. Hence, the word 'performances'. It is almost like a performance where they are trying to send out a message to the world - 'if you frown upon us when we do it in public outside, here is our space'.
Why do homosexuals need a secluded space? Because, not everyone is raedy to take on the harsh society. But, I do take your point about who then takes the responsibilty for shattering existing ideas? My answer would be those homosexuals who are strong enought to face the world.
Let's face it, it is a fight.
Why do you say take homosexuals at face value? I didn't understand that.
And, by the way, she was not sarcastic at any point. She meant it. It showed.
Thanks a ton Sriparna!
your point is taken,
probably the girl thought, oh this little thing of 17 is only for men!!! what a loss!!! sigh
Right Suketu!! Ha! :)
Hey, good one Rakshu. I liked it. I enjoy reading the comments too and I totally agree with Sriparna's comments. I felt the same.
Simply amazing...nd dats wat I call a true journalistic experience:)God bless ya...Keep writing:)
Post a Comment